Search found 211 matches

by XjedeyeX
March 30th, 2009, 4:55 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

lets ignore the cards' designers
by XjedeyeX
March 30th, 2009, 4:47 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

well..

i think those cards were crappy and could have been better than they were, but they were obviously there (along with lost sense/alter) because decipher wanted to push ep1 only alternate format, but never really got any steam with that.
by XjedeyeX
March 30th, 2009, 4:35 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

i agree with everything hunter said here
by XjedeyeX
March 29th, 2009, 8:21 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

I figured since i didn't have anything additional to add to my earlier comments about TFU, rather than bogging this thread down in repeating myself a million times and have you do the same, i'd just let it go and let everyone move on :)
by XjedeyeX
March 29th, 2009, 5:24 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

idunno, jedi and lightsabers are pretty much the 2 biggest and most appealing things about starwars in general

i guess you could get in the brandon schele camp
by XjedeyeX
March 27th, 2009, 1:49 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

maybe BFHI will be on the list?
by XjedeyeX
March 27th, 2009, 1:37 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

i would say grimtaash but that will likely make the top 3.

If we are going with things that are overpowered / do way too much maybe it will be HCF or one of the senate objectives
by XjedeyeX
March 23rd, 2009, 3:27 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

you can stop this any time by posting the next one on the list hunter
by XjedeyeX
March 23rd, 2009, 1:06 am
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

as someone who has ALWAYS publicly hated on non retrieval retrieval, i have no idea why anyone would support it at all, let alone support it on some cards and not others.

I think the biggest argument would have to be logistical though
by XjedeyeX
March 21st, 2009, 11:39 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

xjedeyex, instead of a bunch of errata, i'd LOVE to just see a new rule that defined "take into hand from lost pile" and the variations thereof (placing a card from lost pile on used pile or reserve deck) as retrieval. indeed that would work too. but my distaste for fake retrieval is also rivaled b...
by XjedeyeX
March 21st, 2009, 2:00 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

im mildly surprised this was this high on the list no argument from me about your points.

i have always hated the non retrieval retrieval, its stupid. i would be happy if all those cards (even r3 leia) were errata'd to say retrieve
by XjedeyeX
March 20th, 2009, 12:48 am
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

Coming Soon: Card #14! Courtesy of The Force Unleashed, the streak of LS cards was snapped. Having had that break from the routine, we can now safely return to LS cards! But will the next card on the Countdown be the first non-virtual card? "Stay tuned, find out!" OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO...
by XjedeyeX
March 20th, 2009, 12:33 am
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

technically tom f went undefeated in the finals with wookies, but he likely would have lost to pistone's watto had they played that game considering the text on that card
by XjedeyeX
March 18th, 2009, 4:05 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

Well I think what Hunter was saying (and he can correct me if I'm wrong) is that TFU discourages almost any non jedi ground deck which in turn lessens the number of light decks available to play. available to play != has no cards which may hurt it and or matchups which will usually not go in its fa...
by XjedeyeX
March 18th, 2009, 2:15 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

not trying to bust your balls, but i think "mains" is too vague a term, cause all 5 you listed use some "main"s. chus ebo even has yoda and epp luke i think.
i actually agree with you.

however, i don't think even you would claim that the ebo deck is a 'mains platform' or whatever
by XjedeyeX
March 18th, 2009, 2:06 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

it would depend more on what throwing a jedi meant and how difficult it was than whether or not you can do it. if throwing a jedi was as difficult as choking them with the card then i'd say it probably wouldn't be much of a big deal. i've already said that i'm not a huge fan of the fact that it affe...
by XjedeyeX
March 18th, 2009, 1:52 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

Lets use that test then. What decks other than some mains platform is available for the light side to use?
wookies, dbo, senate, whap v, chu's ebo for starters
by XjedeyeX
March 18th, 2009, 1:41 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

It isn't even a matter of keeping the same deckLISTS, it's a matter of keeping the DECKS at all. I wouldn't even bother to try and adjust the decklists. The decks don't just need a few changes to adapt to the arrival of the new set. That wouldn't do it. The decks are GONE. They AUTO-LOSE to the car...
by XjedeyeX
March 18th, 2009, 3:37 am
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

Who are you to say that it has no impact on the game? It had enormous impact on the game for me. As I've said before, when v17 released I had 9 LS decklists. 6 (SIX!) of those 9 are utterly and completely BURIED by v17. its a new set man. it is a GOOD thing that you can't just keep the same exact d...
by XjedeyeX
March 17th, 2009, 6:48 pm
Forum: Notable Topics
Topic: The Top 20 Cards That Shouldn't Have Been Made
Replies: 4157
Views: 262753

if the card isn't too good and doesn't have any permanent negative effects then you are just arguing based on aesthetics, nothing else. if the fact that it theoretically takes 3 grabbers (and it rarely will) to grab the effects of this card isn't overpowered, ie the effects of the card aren't overpo...

Go to advanced search