Maneuver substitution and modification
- Munchanka
- Member
- Posts: 376
- Joined: May 22nd, 2014, 10:30 pm
- Location: Oakland, CA
- GEMP Username: munchanka
- Contact:
Maneuver substitution and modification
When you have cards like Legacy's Jedi Starfighter where the maneuver = *, and game text says * = pilot's ability, is this the only maneuver the starfighter can have or is this the base maneuver value that can be modified?
Austin Madison
Game Designer, Ameritrash Games
Game Designer, Ameritrash Games
Re: Maneuver substitution and modification
It can be modified. It is not a "reset".
Reset
The changing of a value to a specific new value (such as power=0). When a value is reset (e.g., ion cannons, crashed vehicles, weapons that set forfeit = 0, Lateral Damage), that value is unmodifiable until restored to normal (or until the affected card leaves play). Some cards define their value in their game text, such as Jawa or Brainiac. This is not resetting and may be modified.
Greg Zinn


-
- World Champion
- Posts: 2646
- Joined: February 1st, 2003, 3:50 pm
Re: Maneuver substitution and modification
Does the bolded text only apply to cards with a '*'?Gergall wrote:It can be modified. It is not a "reset".
Reset
The changing of a value to a specific new value (such as power=0). When a value is reset (e.g., ion cannons, crashed vehicles, weapons that set forfeit = 0, Lateral Damage), that value is unmodifiable until restored to normal (or until the affected card leaves play). Some cards define their value in their game text, such as Jawa or Brainiac. This is not resetting and may be modified.

Re: Maneuver substitution and modification
Do you have any specific examples you want to look at?Karrdeshark wrote:Does the bolded text only apply to cards with a '*'?Gergall wrote:It can be modified. It is not a "reset".
Reset
The changing of a value to a specific new value (such as power=0). When a value is reset (e.g., ion cannons, crashed vehicles, weapons that set forfeit = 0, Lateral Damage), that value is unmodifiable until restored to normal (or until the affected card leaves play). Some cards define their value in their game text, such as Jawa or Brainiac. This is not resetting and may be modified.
At the very least, it could be some other symbol. For example, Brainiac famously uses X and Y instead of *
Greg Zinn


Re: Maneuver substitution and modification
The Falcon with Rey piloting? (On phone so don't have text, sorry!)
-
- World Champion
- Posts: 2646
- Joined: February 1st, 2003, 3:50 pm
Re: Maneuver substitution and modification
That's correct, I was thinking of the Falcon:
In proofing, we assumed that meant that its maneuver could no longer be modified because it had been reset. Is that correct?The Falcon wrote:While [Episode VII] Chewie, [Episode VII] Han, or Rey piloting manuver = 6 and immune to attrition < 5."

Re: Maneuver substitution and modification
Yeah that's a reset to 6, no modification possible.
Another example of a reset is Like My Father Before Me resetting Luke's deploy to 6. No modification possible, from Luke's own text or anywhere else.
Another example of a reset is Like My Father Before Me resetting Luke's deploy to 6. No modification possible, from Luke's own text or anywhere else.
Greg Zinn


- puck71
- Member
- Posts: 12897
- Joined: February 17th, 2008, 8:59 pm
- Location: St. Paul, MN
- GEMP Username: puck71
Re: Maneuver substitution and modification
Based on that ar entry, it does seem the falcon is defining its value in its game text and thus would not be a reset.
John Anderson
Proofing, Tournament Committee, GEMP Team
Proofing, Tournament Committee, GEMP Team
Re: Maneuver substitution and modification
I thought that for a minute, but I don't think so.puck71 wrote:Based on that ar entry, it does seem the falcon is defining its value in its game text and thus would not be a reset.
If the printed maneuver was *, And the gametext said "* = 6 if han or rey piloting, 3 otherwise" or somethign to that effect, it would be defining in the game text, and would be modifiable.
Since the printed maneuver is 4 and the gametext says it = 6 when rey/han piloting, then it's a reset. Because it's already defined (in the printed part) and then the gametext resets it. It doesn't define it. Therefore it isn't modifiable.
That's how I see it.
Hopefully gergall can confirm.
Re: Maneuver substitution and modification
Falcon is not "defining" the value in its game text. It more closely resembles the first line of that same quoted AR entry.
The examples of defining are Jawa and Brainiac, cards that have variables (asterisk, X, Y) and you have to read the text to find out what it means.Reset
The changing of a value to a specific new value (such as power=0).
Greg Zinn


-
- World Champion
- Posts: 2646
- Joined: February 1st, 2003, 3:50 pm