The Last Jedi Mafia GAME OVER - SCUM WINS

[Apollyon]

This may be super-obvious, but there's a non-zero chance Hunter is DJ, right? His Maz role claim seems safe, but that seems like an obvious last-ditch effort role claim for the crazy to make since he does in fact know everything that Maz may theoretically know.

Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk

It's entirely possible that Hunter is actually DJ and that JJD is next-leveling us.

[WiseMarsellus]

hunter as dj is ridiculous. no way djhunter kills arebelspy night 1. dj is most likely an inexperienced player

[Meto]

I just had a thought that up-ends a few things. The Batmouse pardon makes way more sense to me if he was Finn and they used the unblockable on Joe. This would give a lot of guys cover (I would never day 1 pardon there!). This makes a Gergall + Hunter scum team make a lot more sense to me. If that's the case, the scum thread probably has a line of discussion during Day 1 that goes, "So we just need to kill Joe and we win, right?" With Hunter's roleclaim...Idk. I don't trust him or Apollyon, lol.

[Meto]

hunter as dj is ridiculous. no way djhunter kills arebelspy night 1. dj is most likely an inexperienced player

Still believe he's really a coroner?

[WiseMarsellus]

no i've said earlier if i had to bet on a dj, it would be apollyon. but i'm willing to give him the benefit of time. if he's the coroner the mutineers want to deal with him. if he's dj the mutineers want to deal with him

[Apollyon]

Let's follow that through its conclusion. We've been assuming that Rey killed Batmouse, so let's assume that DJ killed Batmouse.

Hunter as DJ kills Batmouse.
Rey/Luke kills ARS.
ARS is overwhelmingly likely to be vanilla, so it can't be Luke. It must be Rey using her OPG.
Hunter can claim Maz, since he can confirm rumors.

Holdo, would you mind detaining Hunter tonight? If he's not the SK, he should only show up with 2 targets. If he's SK, he'll have 3 targets (2 lynches and a kill).

[Cam Solusar]

hunter as dj is ridiculous. no way djhunter kills arebelspy night 1. dj is most likely an inexperienced player

Hmm, fair point.

Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk

[Advocate]

hunter as dj is ridiculous. no way djhunter kills arebelspy night 1. dj is most likely an inexperienced player

Scum killed him night one. Joe was playing too hard.

Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk

[Advocate]

Rey had to kill batmouse, no?

Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk

[Gergall]

caldred (6) - Gergall, vhstapes, puck71, darkjediknight11, TacoBill, Advocate
Hunter (2) - caldred, JediJer
darkjediknight11 (1) - WiseMarsellus
Gergall (4) - rhendon, Apollyon, Meto, Cam Solusar
No Lynch (1) - Hunter

Not Voting (1)
Remaker

[puck71]

Rey had to kill batmouse, no?

Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk

There are probably other fringe situations, but it's defeinite most likely.

[Advocate]

But rules wise it had to be Rey unless he used his OPG to override things right?

Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk

[WiseMarsellus]

hunter as dj is ridiculous. no way djhunter kills arebelspy night 1. dj is most likely an inexperienced player

Scum killed him night one. Joe was playing too hard.

Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk

one thing we can be sure of is that apollyon was telling the truth, at least that dj killed arevelspy. think about it. if he’s town he’s truthful. if he’s dj if he lies then the mutineers know he’s dj. if he’s red and he lies then dj knows he’s red

[puck71]

But rules wise it had to be Rey unless he used his OPG to override things right?

Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk

If Rey's voted ended up on Batmouse, yes

[rhendon]

Am I allowed to call Rhendon and wake his ass up lol. Hunter claimed. it's 6am there.

Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk

What the hell? I was up when he claimed. I posted like 10 walls of text. I need to sleep too.

[Meto]

hunter as dj is ridiculous. no way djhunter kills arebelspy night 1. dj is most likely an inexperienced player

Scum killed him night one. Joe was playing too hard.

Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk

one thing we can be sure of is that apollyon was telling the truth, at least that dj killed arevelspy. think about it. if he’s town he’s truthful. if he’s dj if he lies then the mutineers know he’s dj. if he’s red and he lies then dj knows he’s red

This assumes it wasn't a misplay.

[Gergall]

hunter as dj is ridiculous. no way djhunter kills arebelspy night 1. dj is most likely an inexperienced player

Scum killed him night one. Joe was playing too hard.

Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk

one thing we can be sure of is that apollyon was telling the truth, at least that dj killed arevelspy. think about it. if he’s town he’s truthful. if he’s dj if he lies then the mutineers know he’s dj. if he’s red and he lies then dj knows he’s red

I don't think we should overlook incompetence. Apollyon could be making all sorts of mistakes as we discussed a bit back here:
/viewt ... 0#p1213890

FRISTED by Meto

[Gergall]

I'm here to answer any questions btw.

If the votes on me are just a matter of "He is in the Batmouse Defenders band" then yes, I am.

[Cam Solusar]

hunter as dj is ridiculous. no way djhunter kills arebelspy night 1. dj is most likely an inexperienced player

Scum killed him night one. Joe was playing too hard.

Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk

one thing we can be sure of is that apollyon was telling the truth, at least that dj killed arevelspy. think about it. if he’s town he’s truthful. if he’s dj if he lies then the mutineers know he’s dj. if he’s red and he lies then dj knows he’s red

I thought apollyon checked dorshe and said he was killed by a blaster?

Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk

[rhendon]

I mean you know my vote was a joke. I still support no lynch.

I mean you know my vote was a joke. I still support no lynch and cal.