The Last Jedi Mafia GAME OVER - SCUM WINS

[rhendon]

ChangeVote: Cal

[Advocate]

hunter as dj is ridiculous. no way djhunter kills arebelspy night 1. dj is most likely an inexperienced player

Scum killed him night one. Joe was playing too hard.

Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk

one thing we can be sure of is that apollyon was telling the truth, at least that dj killed arevelspy. think about it. if he’s town he’s truthful. if he’s dj if he lies then the mutineers know he’s dj. if he’s red and he lies then dj knows he’s red

Oh, I missed that! He said that. Crap.

Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk

[TacoBill]

I am not Maz.

I think its going to be difficult to orchestrate cal/nolynch, especially when 2 of the people Hunter needed have jumped directly to Gergall, and one may not be back.

[Advocate]

So by no voting or no Lynch where appropriate and only voting for Cal we hide Rey still? And the Rey kills who by rule?

Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk

[rhendon]

I just had a thought that up-ends a few things. The Batmouse pardon makes way more sense to me if he was Finn and they used the unblockable on Joe. This would give a lot of guys cover (I would never day 1 pardon there!). This makes a Gergall + Hunter scum team make a lot more sense to me. If that's the case, the scum thread probably has a line of discussion during Day 1 that goes, "So we just need to kill Joe and we win, right?" With Hunter's roleclaim...Idk. I don't trust him or Apollyon, lol.

Well if Apollyon is lying, then DJ knows. If he is lying, then he is likely scum and DJ can make that attack. DJ shouldn't leave suspected scum alive. He'd rather leave the hidden ones to buy him the time he needs.

If Apollyon is lying to cover up him being DJ, then scum knows and that is not the town's problem either. They will take him out ASAP.

Why would that be the scum's line? I can't imagine scum Hunter ever saying that. I imagine scum Hunter saying "Ok guys we win" as his first post in the thread.

[Cam Solusar]

change vote: caldred

Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk

[rhendon]

So by no voting or no Lynch where appropriate and only voting for Cal we hide Rey still? And the Rey kills who by rule?

Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk

Well if the only votes are Rey and Cal, then Rey has to vote for Cal. Since Leia shouldn't pardon Cal, Rey won't attack because Cal will be lynched.

For God's sake, read the role you are trying to pretend to be as DJ...

[JarJarDrinks]

caldred (8) - Gergall, vhstapes, puck71, darkjediknight11, TacoBill, Advocate, rhendon, Cam Solusar
Hunter (2) - caldred, JediJer
darkjediknight11 (1) - WiseMarsellus
Gergall (2) - Apollyon, Meto
No Lynch(1) - Hunter

Not Voting (1)
Remaker

[Gergall]

caldred (8) - Gergall, vhstapes, puck71, darkjediknight11, TacoBill, Advocate, rhendon, Cam Solusar
Hunter (2) - caldred, JediJer
darkjediknight11 (1) - WiseMarsellus
Gergall (2) - Apollyon, Meto
No Lynch (1) - Hunter

Not Voting (1)
Remaker[/quote]

[puck71]

hunter as dj is ridiculous. no way djhunter kills arebelspy night 1. dj is most likely an inexperienced player

Scum killed him night one. Joe was playing too hard.

Sent from my HTC 10 using Tapatalk

one thing we can be sure of is that apollyon was telling the truth, at least that dj killed arevelspy. think about it. if he’s town he’s truthful. if he’s dj if he lies then the mutineers know he’s dj. if he’s red and he lies then dj knows he’s red

I thought apollyon checked dorshe and said he was killed by a blaster?

Sent from my Pixel 2 using Tapatalk

Yes, that's what he said.

[JediJer]

Ok. I skimmed pages 68 and 69 and skipped the last 2 pages so I don't know exactly what has gone down, but after sleeping on it, tapes is a better lynch than Hunter. Sorry for being so stubborn about it.

I would be fine with a cal/tapes lynch as tapes would give a lot of info. There are some fishy things about his claim that I need to look into further, but it's basically that a first time player likely wouldn't be familiar with the term vanilla. They would claim the role that they received in the pm, which is resistance soldier.

Looks like cal is the current favorite, and I can put my vote there if others think tapes isn't worth lynching today, but for now
change vote vhstapes

[Gergall]

it's basically that a first time player likely wouldn't be familiar with the term vanilla

If you page through the thread and search "vanilla" people are throwing it around a bunch. JJD himself used the word vanilla on pages 1 and 3.

Are you okay with Cal / No Lynch?

[puck71]

So by no voting or no Lynch where appropriate and only voting for Cal we hide Rey still? And the Rey kills who by rule?

If the person Rey votes for gets lynched, nothing happens "by rule"

If the person Rey votes for does NOT get lynched, AND there is a no lynch result, she will automatically shoot at who she voted for.

[JediJer]

it's basically that a first time player likely wouldn't be familiar with the term vanilla

If you page through the thread and search "vanilla" people are throwing it around a bunch. JJD himself used the word vanilla on pages 1 and 3.

Are you okay with Cal / No Lynch?

Yeah I'm ok with a cal no lynch result but would prefer cal tapes.

Also not maz

[WiseMarsellus]

jedijer, if you're town you're tunnel visioning so hard on tapes. do you really think we had two wolves in the noose at the deadline yesterday?

[WiseMarsellus]

not an official votecount, just making a point

caldred (8) - Gergall, vhstapes, puck71, darkjediknight11, TacoBill, Advocate, rhendon, Cam Solusar
Hunter (2) - caldred, JediJer
darkjediknight11 (1) - WiseMarsellus
Gergall (2) - Apollyon, Meto
No Lynch(1) - Hunter

Not Voting (1)
Remaker

i put in green those names that voted for batmouse at a relevant time. the other two names that would have been greened out are dorshe and arebelspy, both dead now, both town. i started off the day suspicious of caldred, and as i've seen who has been targeting him all day i've become less and less. i do not like this lynch at all. i like djk, i like gergall, i would even still like hunter if i didn't know that i'd be lynched next if hunter actually is green. i know it's silly to already have a mutineer team picked out, but they form this trinity of defending batmouse and defending each other, even when they look really really bad

[Meto]

I probably can't be here for the deadline as I start work at noon. The Cal lynch looks like garbage. No lynch doesn't seem like the best play, but I haven't the time or energy to move votes to Gergall or anyone else.

The most useful thing I can do with my vote is probably change vote no lynch

[WiseMarsellus]

if i move to gergall will you go back to him?

[rhendon]

not an official votecount, just making a point

caldred (8) - Gergall, vhstapes, puck71, darkjediknight11, TacoBill, Advocate, rhendon, Cam Solusar
Hunter (2) - caldred,
darkjediknight11 (1) - WiseMarsellus
Gergall (2) - Apollyon, Meto
vhstapes - JediJer
No Lynch(1) - Hunter

Not Voting (1)
Remaker

i put in green those names that voted for batmouse at a relevant time. the other two names that would have been greened out are dorshe and arebelspy, both dead now, both town. i started off the day suspicious of caldred, and as i've seen who has been targeting him all day i've become less and less. i do not like this lynch at all. i like djk, i like gergall, i would even still like hunter if i didn't know that i'd be lynched next if hunter actually is green. i know it's silly to already have a mutineer team picked out, but they form this trinity of defending batmouse and defending each other, even when they look really really bad

Just wanted to make an updated vote count for Wise's point.

[WiseMarsellus]

changevote gergall