WTF? Are you stoned?WiseMarsellus wrote:knowing who rey is shows that i used my detective ability, that i really am r2d2. it was probably an overreaction but i really wanted town to trust me and to move their votes along with me. that didn't materialize, but who knows, maybe cal gets lynched if i don't say that. more likely though, revealing that information was a misplay on my part
I know who Leia is, does that make me anything? No. I also have no idea how you know who Rey is.
That is your role. So which ability says you learn who Rey is? Let's say you targeted someone to see who they targeted. 2 people could have gone at BM last night. Rey/3P0. Do you know if 3P0 is in the game or not? I don't see how you could. So you say you know who Rey is based on what here?R2-D2 may choose one of the following abilities to use, each night.
SA/NF: Each Night, R2-D2 may Investigate a player to determine if they have Night Activity during the current Night.
SA/NF: Each Night, R2-D2 may Investigate a player to determine who they target with any abilities during the current Night.
SA/NF: Each Night, R2-D2 may Investigate a player to determine who targets them with any abilities during the current Night.
Let's say you see who targets someone. Well again those same 2 people were just as likely to go at BM. So do you know who 3P0 targeted or if he is in the game? No. So how do you know Rey? Do you have some secret ability that I don't know about?
Also none of that should give you insight onto Cal. You don't look at the larger picture of the game. You look at short term stuff. Gergall busing Cal is bad short term. It is good long term if he can get town cred and stay hidden for longer, especially when Cal has already picked up a lot of votes on a two noose day. Its likely that he would choose to go down that path rather than out himself defending him. But I know you would out yourself to defend him in this situation for all that short term glory but no long term glory.
All you are basing it on is Gergall voted for Cal (he was no where near the biggest supporter of that lynch; I was and Hunter was). He was more defensive of Hunter. So that should put us into that role rather than him, but you've tunnel visioned on him and I want to know why. Because I'm listed what you're telling me and it doesn't add up. And now you're going to tell me that Gergall being so defensive of Hunter means Hunter = scum. I guess I missed the part where we are playing * candyland mafia instead of an actual mafia game. No way Gergall/Hunter scum team makes that play.