The Last Jedi Mafia GAME OVER - SCUM WINS

[rhendon]

Now how so I get to the observer deck?

Press alt-f4.

Actually just go to your profile control panel. Click on usergroups and click on the observation deck one.

[vhstapes]

How do you people * figure this * out. I am just completely sitting here at a loss for words.

I'm in the same boat lol. I dunno if I just don't have the time to read things carefully enough or what.

So here's where I'm at, in case I die tonight, which seems highly likely...

Scum:
JediJer
Rhendon

Unsure:
Remaker

Town:
Advocate
Puck
Tapes

[arebelspy]

Edit: Whoops. Tried to post in obs deck. Sorry. Nothing relevant to the current state of the game, just berating cam for his night one read of me.

Here's what I posted, in case someone saw, everyone can see:

Spoiler

Show

Cam, IDK how you read me as red.

My night posts were SO GREEN.

Start here:
viewtopic.php?f=693&t=70216&start=840#p1213279

And read the next dozen posts. It's just me scum hunting and trying to piece together the puzzle.

Super town.

All I can figure is I named you as a BM defender, and it was OMGUS. I said you looked red, so you decided I was scum throwing shade.

Thing is, all that was so pro town, you should have been able to see I was green and just mistaken. Everyone else saw it as green, you tunneled. And then blew your OPG for it.

Like I said earlier, I blame baby brain.

Sorry everyone!

[rhendon]

Edit: Whoops. Tried to post in obs deck. Sorry. Nothing relevant to the current state of the game, just berating cam for his night one read of me.

Here's what I posted, in case someone saw, everyone can see:

Spoiler

Show

Cam, IDK how you read me as red.

My night posts were SO GREEN.

Start here:
viewtopic.php?f=693&t=70216&start=840#p1213279

And read the next dozen posts. It's just me scum hunting and trying to piece together the puzzle.

Super town.

All I can figure is I named you as a BM defender, and it was OMGUS. I said you looked red, so you decided I was scum throwing shade.

Thing is, all that was so pro town, you should have been able to see I was green and just mistaken. Everyone else saw it as green, you tunneled. And then blew your OPG for it.

Like I said earlier, I blame baby brain.

Sorry everyone!

Remind me to respond to this in obs deck after game.

[rhendon]

I do think it is sort of amusing that the vanilla townie is worried about dying with Leia out there. She is the obvious target.

If you don't believe I'm Holdo (where I called Meto's role and night 1 list blindly if not), then idk what more I can do.

If you believe I am Holdo, I am also a target. So there are at least 2 targets way above you. I have the toughest decision tonight to make. Do I protect Scott for the for sure help and leave myself exposed; or do I go for the scum attacker and hope to save Scott and myself. Scott is a much bigger threat with the pardons and secret vote. But I have potential to save people at night. Ughh.

So far my thinking is this:

Town:
Me
Advocate

Leaning town:
Tapes
JJ

Neutral:
Apollyon
Remaker
Puck

No clue at this point who is or isn't scum.

[puck71]

How do you people * figure this * out.

I feel the same way every game. I re-read the same posts and votes as other people, and they seem to get something out of it. I only do that SOMETIMES and usually only if someone says something is there to look for.

Like the only town I'm sure of 100% right now are me and advocate.

However, unless I'm missing something, doesn't rhendon basically HAVE to be Holdo (and thus town)? Holdo was alive as of last night, and the three deaths last night had claimed other roles, which I highly doubt the sheriff would do (though it is technically possible). And the deaths today can't really be Holdo either. Meto was detained, which rules him out. I can't imagine a scenario where Cam wasn't actually Rey. I also can't imagine caldred not claiming or counter-claiming if he was Holdo, but again I guess it's possible. Also, Holdo can't be the traitor. The other option is that someone still alive is Holdo and not counter-claiming, but I can't really wrap my head around that making much sense. But again, it's possible. So despite what meto said/did, the observable facts have rhendon at like 98% town for me.

But the other 4 (apollyon, vhstapes, jedijer, remaker)? I guess 2 or 3 of them must be scum, but hell if I know which ones.

[rhendon]

Obs deck, please do a poll on what I'm supposed to do because I have no idea.

1. Detain Advocate
2. Fake detain Advocate; Try to detain scum attacker
3. Just try to detain scum attacker
4. Do nothing

[Advocate]

If we have a luke, he obviously needs to protect me, yes?

[rhendon]

If we have a luke, he obviously needs to protect me, yes?

If we have a Luke, he should claim. He can't be attacked and I don't want to detain him on accident.

[JediJer]

Caldred better not have been Luke

[Advocate]

If he was, he would be communning, no?

[Advocate]

I had a gut feeling to put my votes on Remaker at the end of the day yesterday. Not sure if it matters or not.

[Advocate]

If I die, I really am leary about Remaker

[puck71]

IID

If you look at my other post tonight, you'll see why I highly believe rhendon to be town, so him, me, and advocate are my townies.

Of the remaining 4, 2 or 3 are scum.

My first choice is apollyon. He lied, he performed actions without asking about what the best move might be (starting his opg yesterday might have been a good option, but we never got a chance to talk about it), and all the other possible traitors we've talked about have turned up green. He might not even be the coroner at all, and just got lucky claiming an unassigned role.

My other scum pick from that bunch is remaker. I don't have any evidence but it seems like there's always a scum lurker who sticks around for a long time.

[JarJarDrinks]

sry gotta be quick.


There was no detainment

rhendon - Resistance - Killed Night 3

Day 4 ends 9/9 @ 4pm

There is ONE noose.

[JediJer]

vote puck
He puts me in his scum list and then a couple posts later totally changes his reads.
I could also get behind a remaker lynch.

[JediJer]

If he was, he would be communning, no?

Considering how poorly he played the whole game, I wouldn't put it past him to screw us over even more by not communing

[JediJer]

Also, won't be able to check the thread very often today.

[puck71]

I didn't have you in a scum list, I said I didn't know which of those 4 were scum. I still don't but I had time to put more thought into it for my iid post. And based on that,

vote: apollyon

[puck71]

I'm out of town most of the weekend so I won't be able to post too much either. I should be fairly available Sunday though.